I may not be posting poems for a while. I am busy grading a huge stack of virtual
papers. Just as importantly, I am stung to
my core by the upcoming election, one that will determine if America loses its
republic to a fascist dictatorship under the most disgusting human being I myself
have ever encountered in a public figure within my country.
What’s most disturbing to me, even more than his conviction
on felonies, is that Donald Trump has been found liable for rape in a court of
law twice and, as well, dozens of women have credibly accused him of sexual
assault. I will leave aside the many other
reviling aspects of this racist, sexist malignant narcissist, who has wallowed
in greed and fraud all his life; otherwise, I could write all night. I will instead conclude with the most heartbreaking
aspect of all of it: despite his crimes, sins and unrepentant hate
and demagoguery, his psychopathic lack of conscience, his bankruptcies both
financial and moral, even so, despite all this, and despite overwhelming documentation
disproving his big lies, such as that the 2020 election was stolen, about half
the population of the United States, millions of people, even after ten years of exposure
to the chaos--to his dysfunction, abuse and incessant spew of lies--are still going
to vote for him.
The perpetual question I hear, and many of us hear, is why? Why are so many people going for Trump?
Kamala Harris is obviously highly competent, whereas Trump is
obviously incompetent, even leaving aside his disgusting, wretched disordered soul. Many of his followers, in fact, say they don’t
like him as a person; and yet are going to vote for him anyway. What is going on?
My answer, which I have expressed on this blog before, is this: White Protestant heteronormative patriarchy
has always ruled this country. A change
would be as dificult as it would be profound. It would be an historic, even epochal, accomplishment.
Trump is the spearhead of the longstanding entitlement of Whiteness to keep the throne--and so many people want this, want Whiteness to reign, that it doesn’t matter
that Trump is a grossly wicked, egregeiously unfair man, or that he is incapable of sane management. Indeed, he has been professional diagnosed by numerous psychologists, who have written a best-selling anthology titled, "The Dangerous Case of Donald Trump."
Isabel Wilkerson explains the situation with far more clarity, detail
and insight than me. Wilkerson does so in
her book, “Caste: The Origins of our Discontents.”
Here’s how a New York Times book reviewer started off his
review of it:
A critic shouldn’t often deal in superlatives. He or she is
here to explicate, to expand context and to make fine distinctions. But
sometimes a reviewer will shout as if into a mountaintop megaphone. I recently
came upon William Kennedy’s review of “One Hundred Years of Solitude,” which he
called “the first piece of literature since the Book of Genesis that should be
required reading for the entire human race.” Kennedy wasn’t far off.
I had these thoughts while reading Isabel Wilkerson’s new
book, “Caste: The Origins of Our Discontents.” It’s an extraordinary document,
one that strikes me as an instant American classic and almost certainly the
keynote nonfiction book of the American century thus far. It made the back of
my neck prickle from its first pages, and that feeling never went away.
I told more than one person, as I moved through my days this
past week, that I was reading one of the most powerful nonfiction books I’d
ever encountered.”
https://www.nytimes.com/2020/07/31/books/review-caste-isabel-wilkerson-origins-of-our-discontents.html
In short, according to Wilkerson, America has been saddled with a caste system ever
since its earliest roots, going back to the revelations of the 1619 Project. Kamala Harris represents the decline of our traditional caste system. Trump is its continuation and fortification. Trump takes the hate and rage of the caste
system’s racism, sexism, homophobia and other oppressions and turns them loose on those who would challenge the old ways.
Trump is attempting to do what the White-ruled system has
always done: shut down protest with fear,
terror and the threat of violence. Once
he gets full power, he will use actual violence, and so will his followers
across the country, down to the smallest town and village. In my tiny town of 1000 population, there are
a number of Trumpers who are filled with rage, stoked by Trump’s words, and who
own assault rifles, these being easy to purchase in the USA.
Wilkerson says that people support Trump--support the caste
system--because they see it as being in their own selfish best interest. Mostly, these are White people, and mostly
White males within that group, that is, the males who are at the very top of the caste structure. Black and brown people who
support Trump do so because, like everywhere in the world and throughout
history, some people in oppressed groups will serve the ruling class dutifully
to get ahead, even and perhaps especially by turning on their own. Turning on your own is required and rewarded by a segregated slot in the hierarchy.
So, America is at a crossroads. One of Trump’s slogans is “Bring American
Back.” One of Harris’s slogans is, “Not
Going Back.”
Because America is still by far the strongest country, both militarily and economically, the result of the upcoming election
will tilt the whole world--toward either fascism under Trump, or democracy under
Harris.
I’ve argued many times on this blog that rulership by a cult-charisma dictator is an ancient, primitive form of governance. Its essence is nothing but 'might makes right.'
Democracy, on the other hand, is an advanced form of ethics technology. Democracy embraces the concepts of humanism--equality, human rights and rational
decision-making--to advance the pursuit of happiness for everyone.
If Trump wins, the world will slide toward cult-charisma dictatorship even more that it already has, and the result will be a primitive global
standard of government, one that is centered in the irrational chest-thumping of a few insecure males.
If Harris wins, the world has a serious chance of advancing
its overall ethics technology. This is
critical, because without advanced ethics tech, humanity will not have
the maturity to properly manage its other advancing techs, such as weapons,
robots, and AI.
Again, either we evolve our collective conscience--by
advancing our ethics tech--or we perish under the rule of petty tyrants.
I believe everything--not just for America, but for the
entire human world--rests on this election.
We will either be ruled by ignorance, or by reason.
Trump, indeed, denies that global warming even exists. The vast body of scientific evidence, and the climate change happening right before our very eyes, the mutating of the continents and the oceans, mean nothing to Trump, simply because they conflict with what he arrogantly opines. He sees
himself as a god. A messiah. And he has surrounded himself by those who will fawn before his fake omniscience, a retinue of lickspittles who will tell him that he is always right, always wearing the emperor’s
new clothes.
I personally believe that it will be very hard for Harris to
win. She is up against the White male caste
system that has existed for hundreds of years. It is also fair to say, given the
seamlessness of misogyny, that she is up against 12,000 years of
patriarchy. Harris, if she wins, will be
the strongest person in the world. A
woman. A non-White woman. And she will not be a placeholder for patriarchy, as
were the sprinkle of women in the past who ruled over various city and nation
states. It’s not as if Elizabeth or
Cleopatra worked in great portion, if they did at all, to advance women’s rights.
Harris and everyone behind her is up against
patriarchy. And the cruelty of patriarchy
has always been at the top. It has never ruled with logic, or with fairness. But instead with a fist.
Still, Harris might win. And what a fantastic
victory that would be. Not only for the Democratic
Party, but for people everywhere, in every country across our barbaric, wretched,
struggling yet hopeful, naturally wondrous globe.
It won’t be a final victory, not by any
means. The battle to advance the
collective human consciousness will go on. However,
if Trump wins, I believe we will be stuck with patriarchy and all its ignorance
and cruelty until the end of civilization. I predict that this end will come fairly soon,
probably within decades. We’re on track for WWIII, after all, with startling similarities to Europe in the 1930s. Putin invading Ukraine. China eyeing Taiwan. Israel expanding a war in the middle east, while committing genocide and ethnic cleansing.
'Never Again,' the motto meant to ward us from another Holocaust, has fallen before Netanyahu's genocidal appeal to 1 Samuel 15:3, where the Amalekites are not only slain, down to the last woman and child, but also their animals slaughtered and lands salted.
Yes, we hover on the edge of the end. Full war. Full Fascism. But there is still a flicker of candlelight in the dark. A hope that we can walk out of this underworld labyrinth and find our way, eventually, onto a full-bodied path of light.
I hope and pray to the Angels. The Angels, as I see them, are non-religious. The Good transcends any one religion. Religions are simply
different mythic routes to approach the Good, but must be shorn of the biases and dysfunctions which lead their adherents astray. There are Angels for all
of us. Good beings, somewhere, even if
only in our minds, beyond us. Call them
by some other name, if you wish. The Good is real. If Evil is real, and it is, for we can all see it in the crystallized, maximized hate of ethno-nationalist political movements, then so is the Good. And so, too, are Angels, at least as I have framed them.
We can as a species approach the Good together, down a reasonable, loving path. But we must dare to embrace
the truth of equality, a simple truth underscored so long ago in that immortal statement: Do to others as you would have them do to
you.
I pray for all of us.
I pray to the Angels. I pray for all of human fate. This is a turning point for Civilization, one way or the other.
=================================
11/1 ... eds